This whole subtopic is higher level. Nothing in it is on an SL paper.
Educerie · IB Diploma · Physics
Theme A Space, time and motion · A.5 Galilean and special relativity
What you must be able to do
| You must be able to | Level | What it looks like in the exam |
|---|---|---|
| Describe reference frames and events, and say what makes a frame inertial | HL only | Paper 1A, or one mark inside a longer question |
| State Galilean relativity and use x′ = x − vt, t′ = t and u′ = u − v | HL only | "Calculate the velocity of the ball measured by…" (2 marks) |
| State the two postulates of special relativity | HL only | "State the two postulates" (2 marks) |
| Use the Lorentz transformations x′ = γ(x − vt) and t′ = γ(t − vx/c²) | HL only | "Calculate the coordinates of event E in frame S′" (3 to 4 marks) |
| Use the relativistic velocity addition equation | HL only | "Determine the speed of B measured by A" (2 to 3 marks) |
| Use the invariance of the space-time interval | HL only | "Show that the interval is the same in both frames" (2 marks) |
| Identify proper time and proper length, and calculate time dilation and length contraction | HL only | "Calculate the time measured by the Earth observer" (2 marks) plus "State which observer measures the proper time" (1 mark) |
| Explain the relativity of simultaneity | HL only | "Explain why the two events are not simultaneous for…" (3 marks) |
| Draw and read space-time diagrams, including tan θ = v/c and the axes of a second frame | HL only | "On the diagram, draw the ct′ and x′ axes" (2 marks); "Determine the time of event P in S′" (2 marks) |
| Explain how muon decay experiments support time dilation and length contraction | HL only | "Explain, from the muon's frame and from the Earth frame…" (4 to 6 marks) |
Before you start
You need A.1: displacement, velocity, and the idea that a velocity is always measured relative to something. You need to be comfortable rearranging an equation with a square root in it, and with powers of ten, because c = 3.00 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹ makes every number in this subtopic large or small. Nothing else is assumed. Relativity feels strange, but the algebra is short.
1The idea in one paragraph
Two observers moving steadily past each other give the same event different coordinates. Newton's rule for relating them was simple: positions shift by vt, times are identical, velocities subtract. That is Galilean relativity, and it works perfectly at everyday speeds. It fails for light, because every observer who measures the speed of light gets the same answer, however fast they are moving. Einstein took that fact as a starting point, and the price was that time and space stop being the same for everyone. Moving clocks run slow, moving objects are shorter, and two events that are simultaneous for one observer are not for another. The Lorentz transformations are the rules that replace Galilean ones, and space-time diagrams are the picture that makes them visible. The one thing every observer agrees on is a combination of time and distance called the space-time interval.
2Reference frames and Galilean relativity
An event is something that happens at one place at one instant: a lamp flashing, a ball being caught. A reference frame is a set of rulers and synchronised clocks that an observer uses to give each event a position x and a time t. An inertial reference frame is one that is not accelerating: an observer in it sees a body with no resultant force on it stay at rest or move at constant velocity. A train running smoothly on straight track is, to a good approximation, an inertial frame; a car taking a sharp bend is not.
Newton's laws hold in every inertial frame. A ball dropped in the smooth train falls straight down, exactly as it does on the platform; no experiment done inside the train can tell you whether it is moving. That statement, that the laws of mechanics are the same in all inertial reference frames, is Galilean relativity.
Figure 1 sets up the standard arrangement you will use for the rest of this subtopic. Frame S is the platform. Frame S′ is the train, moving at velocity v in the +x direction relative to S. Their origins coincide at t = t′ = 0.
After time t, the origin of S′ has moved a distance vt. An event at position x in S is therefore at x − vt in S′. In Newton's world time is universal, so both frames give the event the same time. These are the Galilean transformation equations:
x′ = x − vt and t′ = t
Follow a moving object and they give velocities too. If the object moves at u in S, it moves at
u′ = u − v in S′
A lamp on the platform flashes at x = 200 m, t = 5.0 s. The train moves at v = 30 m s⁻¹.
A drone flies along the platform at u = 35 m s⁻¹. Its velocity measured on the train is u′ = 35 − 30 = 5 m s⁻¹. A drone flying the other way at u = −35 m s⁻¹ has u′ = −35 − 30 = −65 m s⁻¹. Signs matter: u, u′ and v are all measured along +x.
3The problem with light, and the two postulates
Now apply u′ = u − v to a beam of light moving at c along +x. Galilean relativity says an observer on a train moving at v measures the light at c − v. By the late nineteenth century there were two reasons to doubt that. Maxwell's theory of electromagnetism predicts a single speed for light, c, calculated from two constants of electricity and magnetism, with no mention of who is measuring it. And experiments designed to detect the Earth's motion through space by changes in the measured speed of light, most famously Michelson and Morley's in 1887, found no change.
Einstein, in 1905, treated these results as a law of nature and built everything else on them. The two postulates of special relativity are:
1. The laws of physics are the same in all inertial reference frames.
2. The speed of light in a vacuum is the same, c, for all inertial observers, whatever the motion of the source or the observer.
The first extends Galilean relativity from mechanics to all of physics, including electromagnetism. The second is the shock. If two observers moving relative to each other both measure the same light pulse at the same speed, then they must disagree about distances or times, or both. The rest of this page is the working-out of that disagreement.
4The Lorentz transformations
The equations that respect both postulates are the Lorentz transformations. For the same set-up as Figure 1:
x′ = γ(x − vt) and t′ = γ(t − vx/c²), where γ = 1 / √(1 − v²/c²)
γ, the Lorentz factor, is always at least 1. You are not asked to derive these equations, only to use them. The data booklet also gives them in terms of intervals, Δx′ = γ(Δx − vΔt) and Δt′ = γ(Δt − vΔx/c²), which is the form to use for the separation between two events.
Figure 2 shows how γ behaves. At everyday speeds it is 1 to many decimal places: for an airliner at 300 m s⁻¹, γ − 1 is about 5 × 10⁻¹³. Then γ is 1.25 at 0.60c, 1.67 at 0.80c, 2.0 at about 0.866c, and it grows without limit as v approaches c. Put γ = 1 and v/c² ≈ 0 into the Lorentz equations and you get x′ = x − vt and t′ = t: Galilean relativity is the low-speed limit of special relativity, which is why Newton was never caught out by a train.
Worked example. Frame S′ moves at v = 0.60c relative to S, so γ = 1 / √(1 − 0.36) = 1.25. An event happens at x = 1500 m, t = 4.0 μs in S. Find its coordinates in S′.
Notice that t′ is not t. In special relativity the time of an event depends on the frame, and it depends on where the event is: the vx/c² term.
A tidy way to work is in units where c is simple. Light travels 300 m in 1 μs, so if you measure distances in metres and times in microseconds, c = 300 m μs⁻¹ and 0.60c = 180 m μs⁻¹.
5Relativistic velocity addition
The Lorentz transformations replace u′ = u − v with:
u′ = (u − v) / (1 − uv/c²)
Here u is an object's velocity measured in S, v is the velocity of S′ relative to S, and u′ is the object's velocity measured in S′. All three are along the x axis, with signs.
Two spacecraft approach the Earth from opposite sides, each at 0.80c relative to the Earth. What is the velocity of craft B measured by craft A? Put A's rest frame as S′, moving at v = +0.80c. Craft B moves at u = −0.80c in the Earth frame S.
Galilean addition would give −1.60c, faster than light. The relativistic answer is less than c, as it must be. Now test the formula on light itself: put u = c.
Every observer gets c, whatever v is. The second postulate is built into the formula. Watch the sign in the denominator: when u and v point opposite ways, uv is negative and the denominator becomes 1 + |uv|/c².
6The space-time interval, proper time and proper length
Two observers disagree about Δx and about Δt between two events. They agree on one combination of them, the space-time interval Δs:
(Δs)² = (cΔt)² − (Δx)², the same in every inertial frame
It is an invariant, like the length of a rod that looks different from different angles but is the same rod. Check it with the event of section 4 (separated from the origin event x = 0, t = 0):
Same number. That is also the fastest way to check a Lorentz calculation.
The interval gives two special measurements their meaning.
The proper time interval Δt₀ between two events is the time measured in the frame in which the two events happen at the same place. It is the time read by a single clock that is present at both events, such as the wristwatch of a traveller who is there when each thing happens. In that frame Δx = 0, so (Δs)² = (cΔt₀)²: the interval is just the proper time multiplied by c.
The proper length L₀ of an object is its length measured in the frame in which the object is at rest.
Say both definitions in these words. "Proper" does not mean correct; every frame's measurement is equally correct. It means "belonging to": the proper time belongs to the clock that is at both events, the proper length to the frame the object sits in.
7Time dilation and length contraction
Δt = γΔt₀ and L = L₀/γ
Time dilation. The time between two events is shortest in the frame where they happen at the same place (the proper time). In every other frame it is longer, by the factor γ. A spacecraft travels at 0.80c (γ = 5/3) and the astronaut's watch records 3.0 years between leaving one star and reaching the next. Both events happen at the astronaut, so the watch reads the proper time.
Length contraction. An object is longest in its own rest frame. Measured from a frame in which it moves along its length, it is shorter by the factor γ. The spacecraft is 120 m long at rest, so observers who watch it pass at 0.80c measure L = 120 ÷ (5/3) = 72 m. Only the length along the direction of motion contracts; its width does not.
The two effects are symmetric. The astronaut sees the Earth's clocks run slow and the Earth's rulers contracted, by the same γ. There is no contradiction, because the two observers also disagree about which events are simultaneous (section 8), and "whose clock is slow" is a comparison that needs simultaneity to be defined.
Two checks save more marks than any formula. Identify the proper quantity before you calculate, and check the direction: the proper time is the shortest time and the proper length the longest length.
These are real effects, not illusions caused by light taking time to arrive. They are what the measurements give after light travel time has been allowed for.
8The relativity of simultaneity
Two events that happen at the same time in one frame do not, in general, happen at the same time in another. Look at the interval form of the time transformation:
Δt′ = γ(Δt − vΔx/c²)
If two events are simultaneous in S, Δt = 0, but they are at different places, Δx ≠ 0, then Δt′ = −γvΔx/c², which is not zero.
Two lamps stand 600 m apart beside a track and flash at the same instant in the ground frame S. A train passes at 0.60c.
In the train's frame the flashes are 1.5 μs apart. The negative sign says that the lamp at larger x, the one the train is travelling towards, flashes first. A passenger is not misreading their clocks: in the train frame, that lamp really does flash first.
Two points keep this from turning into nonsense. Events that are simultaneous and at the same place (Δx = 0) are simultaneous for everyone. And the order of two events can only be reversed if no signal could travel between them, which is why cause always comes before effect for every observer.
9Space-time diagrams
A space-time diagram plots events on axes of position x (horizontal) and ct (vertical). Using ct rather than t puts both axes in metres, and makes the path of light a line at 45°. Figure 3 is one.
Each event is a point. The history of a particle is a line of events, its world line. The guide limits you to constant velocity, so world lines are straight.
- A particle at rest in S (A in Figure 3) has a vertical world line: x stays the same while ct increases.
- A particle moving at v (B) has a world line tilted from the ct axis by an angle θ, with
tan θ = v/c
- Light has v = c, so θ = 45°. No world line can be tilted further from the ct axis than 45°, because nothing travels faster than light.
B moves at 0.5c, so θ = tan⁻¹ 0.5 = 26.6°. Event E, where B passes A, is a point both world lines share.
Adding the axes of a second frame. The ct′ axis of frame S′ is the world line of the origin of S′, so it is tilted from the ct axis by θ, where tan θ = v/c. The x′ axis is the set of events with ct′ = 0, and it is tilted up from the x axis by the same angle θ. The two primed axes close towards the 45° light line like a pair of scissors; the faster S′ moves, the more they close. Figure 4 draws them for v = 0.60c, θ = 31°.
To read an event's coordinates in either frame, draw lines through it parallel to the other axis:
- For S: drop a line parallel to the ct axis to read x, and a line parallel to the x axis to read ct. This is what you always do on a graph.
- For S′: draw a line parallel to the x′ axis to meet the ct′ axis and read ct′, and a line parallel to the ct′ axis to meet the x′ axis and read x′.
Figure 4 uses the event from section 4 in units of 300 m (so ct = 4 means 1200 m, or 4.0 μs). The two dashed amber lines reach the primed axes at ct′ = 1.25 and x′ = 3.25, which are 375 m and 975 m, the Lorentz results.
Simultaneity on the diagram. In S, events with the same ct lie on a horizontal line. In S′, events with the same ct′ lie on a line parallel to the x′ axis, which is tilted. Figure 5 shows events A and B that are simultaneous in S. The lines through them parallel to x′ meet the ct′ axis at different heights, and B's is lower, so in S′ event B happens first. This is section 8 drawn rather than calculated.
The scales are not the same. One unit on the ct′ axis is longer on the page than one unit on the ct axis. The guide says the scales are set by lines of constant space-time interval: because (ct)² − x² is the same in both frames, the curve (ct)² − x² = 1 passes through ct = 1 on the ct axis and through ct′ = 1 on the ct′ axis. Those curves are hyperbolae, drawn in Figure 6. The curve x² − (ct)² = 1 does the same job for the x and x′ axes.
Figure 6 also shows time dilation and length contraction as geometry. The tick ct′ = 1 on the S′ clock's world line sits at ct = 1.25 in S: S sees one unit of S′ time take γ = 1.25 units of its own. Length contraction can be read the same way, by comparing where the two ends of a moving rod are at one instant in each frame. You will not be asked to construct hyperbolae, only to know that they are why the scales differ.
10The evidence: muon decay
Muons are unstable particles made when cosmic rays hit the upper atmosphere. At rest, a population of muons decays with a half-life of about 1.5 μs. They arrive at the Earth's surface at speeds close to c, in numbers far larger than a Newtonian calculation allows. Measurements of this, comparing muon counts on a mountain with counts at sea level, were among the first direct tests of time dilation.
Work it through. A detector on a mountain top counts muons moving straight down at 0.995c (γ = 10.0). A second detector is 3.0 km lower, at sea level. What fraction of the muons should reach the lower detector?
Without relativity:
In the Earth frame, with time dilation. The muon's decay runs on its own clock, which is present at both events (passing the top detector, passing the bottom one), so it measures the proper time.
In the muon's frame, with length contraction. The muon is at rest, and the mountain rushes up at 0.995c. The 3.0 km height is a proper length in the Earth frame, so the muon measures it contracted: 3000 ÷ 10.0 = 300 m. That takes 300 ÷ (0.995 × 3.00 × 10⁸) = 1.0 μs to go past, the same 0.67 half-lives, the same 63%.
Figure 7 puts the two stories side by side.
The Earth frame explains the survival by time dilation; the muon frame explains it by length contraction. Both give the same prediction, and the prediction matches the counts. That is what the guide means when it says muon experiments are evidence for both effects. The mistake to avoid is mixing the frames: using the contracted 300 m with the dilated 10 μs gives nonsense.
c is a limit built into the theory, not an engineering problem, much as absolute zero is in thermal physics.
11Where marks are lost
- Putting γ on the wrong side. A moving clock's time is the longer one: Δt = γΔt₀, and a moving length is the shorter one: L = L₀/γ. If a moving clock ends up recording more time, swap.
- Not stating which frame measures the proper quantity. "State which observer measures the proper time" is its own mark. The answer is the observer for whom both events happen at the same place, with the reason.
- Treating "proper" as "correct". Every frame's measurements are equally valid. Proper means measured in the frame where the events share a place, or the object is at rest.
- Forgetting the vx/c² term. t′ = t is Galilean. In special relativity the time of an event depends on its position.
- Sign errors in velocity addition. u, u′ and v are all measured along +x. Two bodies approaching each other have opposite signs, which turns 1 − uv/c² into 1 + |uv|/c².
- Measuring the world-line angle from the x axis. In tan θ = v/c, θ is measured from the ct axis. Light is at 45° from both.
- Assuming the primed axes share the unprimed scale. A unit on ct′ is longer on the page; the hyperbolae set it.
- Mixing frames in the muon problem. In the Earth frame use the full 3.0 km with the dilated muon clock; in the muon frame use the contracted height and the muon's own time. Never combine the two.
12Draw it right
- Label the axes x and ct (the guide's convention), with ct vertical, and use equal scales so light is at 45°.
- Draw light as a 45° line and label it; every other world line must be steeper.
- Draw the ct′ axis tilted from ct by θ, and the x′ axis tilted from x by the same θ, towards the light line. Mark θ and write tan θ = v/c.
- To read an S′ coordinate, draw a construction line through the event parallel to the other primed axis, with a ruler, and mark where it meets.
- Show simultaneity in S as a horizontal line and simultaneity in S′ as a line parallel to x′.
- For a Galilean diagram (Figure 1), mark v, the shift vt, and both x and x′ to the event.
- In a two-frame muon answer, label which frame each part refers to, and give the distance and time for that frame only.
13Try it
Marks in brackets. c = 3.00 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹. Answers and marker's notes follow.
Q1. State the two postulates of special relativity. 2 marks
Q2. Frame S′ moves at 0.50c relative to frame S along their common x axis; the origins coincide at t = t′ = 0. An event occurs at x = 600 m, t = 3.0 μs in S. 5 marks
(a) Calculate γ. 1 mark
(b) Calculate x′ and t′ for the event. 2 marks
(c) Show that the space-time interval between this event and the origin event is the same in both frames. 2 marks
Q3. In a particle accelerator, two protons travel towards each other, each at 0.90c in the laboratory frame. Calculate the speed of one proton measured in the rest frame of the other, and comment on the Galilean answer. 3 marks
Q4. (Data-based, Paper 1B style. Invented data.) A detector on a mountain records 600 muons per hour travelling vertically downwards at 0.990c. An identical detector 2000 m lower records 390 muons per hour. The half-life of muons at rest is 1.5 μs. 6 marks
(a) Calculate the time, in the Earth frame, for a muon to travel from the upper to the lower detector. 1 mark
(b) Calculate the fraction of muons expected to reach the lower detector if relativity is ignored. 2 marks
(c) Calculate the fraction expected when time dilation is taken into account. 2 marks
(d) Comment on whether the data support special relativity. 1 mark
Q5. A space-time diagram for frame S shows the ct′ axis of frame S′ at an angle of 22° to the ct axis. 4 marks
(a) Calculate the speed of S′ relative to S. 1 mark
(b) Events X and Y lie on a line parallel to the x axis, with Y at the larger value of x. Explain, with reference to the diagram, which event happens first in S′. 3 marks
Q6. A spacecraft with a proper length of 80 m passes a space station at 0.60c. A lamp on the spacecraft flashes every 2.0 s, measured on the spacecraft. 4 marks
(a) Calculate the length of the spacecraft measured by the station. 1 mark
(b) Calculate the time between flashes measured by the station. 2 marks
(c) State which observer measures the proper time between flashes, and why. 1 mark
14In one breath
Newton's laws hold in every inertial (non-accelerating) frame: that is Galilean relativity, with x′ = x − vt, t′ = t and u′ = u − v. Light breaks it, so special relativity starts from two postulates: the laws of physics are the same in all inertial frames, and every inertial observer measures light in a vacuum at c. The Lorentz transformations x′ = γ(x − vt) and t′ = γ(t − vx/c²), with γ = 1/√(1 − v²/c²), replace the Galilean ones and shrink back to them at low speed; velocities combine as u′ = (u − v)/(1 − uv/c²), which never exceeds c. Every observer agrees on the interval (cΔt)² − (Δx)². Proper time is measured where two events share a place and is the shortest; proper length is measured where the object is at rest and is the longest: Δt = γΔt₀, L = L₀/γ. Events simultaneous at different places in one frame are not simultaneous in another. On a ct–x diagram light runs at 45°, a world line leans from ct by θ with tan θ = v/c, the primed axes close towards the light line, lines of equal ct′ run parallel to x′, and hyperbolae of constant interval set the scales. Muons reach sea level: time dilation explains it in the Earth frame, length contraction in the muon's.
Answers
Q1. The laws of physics are the same in all inertial reference frames. The speed of light in a vacuum is the same for all inertial observers, independent of the motion of the source and of the observer. 1 for each postulate. "The speed of light is constant" without "for all inertial observers" scores 0 for the second: it must say who measures it. "Laws of physics are the same everywhere" without "inertial frames" scores 0 for the first.
Q2. (a) γ = 1 ÷ √(1 − 0.50²) = 1.15. (b) vt = 0.50 × 3.00 × 10⁸ × 3.0 × 10⁻⁶ = 450 m, so x′ = 1.155 × (600 − 450) = 173 m. vx/c² = (0.50 × 600) ÷ (3.00 × 10⁸) = 1.0 × 10⁻⁶ s, so t′ = 1.155 × (3.0 − 1.0) μs = 2.31 μs. (c) In S: (ct)² − x² = (900)² − 600² = 8.1 × 10⁵ − 3.6 × 10⁵ = 4.5 × 10⁵ m². In S′: ct′ = 3.00 × 10⁸ × 2.31 × 10⁻⁶ = 693 m, and 693² − 173² = 4.8 × 10⁵ − 3.0 × 10⁴ = 4.5 × 10⁵ m². The same. (a) A1. (b) A1 for x′, A1 for t′; forgetting the vx/c² term gives t′ = 3.46 μs and scores 0 for t′. (c) M1 for evaluating (cΔt)² − (Δx)² in both frames, A1 for both equal to 4.5 × 10⁵ m² (accept small rounding differences).
Q3. Let S′ be the rest frame of proton A, moving at v = +0.90c. Proton B moves at u = −0.90c in the laboratory. u′ = (−0.90c − 0.90c) ÷ (1 − (−0.90)(0.90)) = −1.80c ÷ 1.81 = −0.994c, so the speed is 0.994c. Galilean addition gives 1.80c, faster than light, which contradicts the second postulate; the relativistic result stays below c. M1 for substituting with u and v of opposite sign, A1 for 0.994c (accept 0.99c), R1 for noting the Galilean answer exceeds c. Using u = +0.90c gives 0 and scores M0 A0.
Q4. (a) t = 2000 ÷ (0.990 × 3.00 × 10⁸) = 6.73 μs. (b) Number of half-lives = 6.73 ÷ 1.5 = 4.49. Fraction = (½)4.49 = 0.045. (c) γ = 1 ÷ √(1 − 0.990²) = 7.09. Proper time = 6.73 ÷ 7.09 = 0.950 μs, which is 0.633 half-lives. Fraction = (½)0.633 = 0.645, about 0.64. (d) Measured fraction = 390 ÷ 600 = 0.65. This agrees with the relativistic prediction (0.64) and is far from the non-relativistic one (0.045), so the data support time dilation. (a) A1. (b) M1 for the number of half-lives, A1 for 0.045 (accept 0.04 to 0.05). (c) M1 for dividing by γ to get the muon's proper time, A1 for 0.64 to 0.65. (d) A1 for comparing 0.65 with both predictions and a conclusion. Multiplying the time by γ instead of dividing gives a survival fraction near zero and loses both (c) marks.
Q5. (a) tan θ = v/c, so v = c × tan 22° = 0.404c = 1.2 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹. (b) Events with equal ct′ lie on lines parallel to the x′ axis, which slopes upwards from the x axis at 22°. Draw such a line through each event to the ct′ axis. Because the lines slope upwards to the right, the line through Y, which is further along x, meets the ct′ axis lower down. So Y has the smaller ct′, and Y happens first in S′. (a) A1. (b) R1 for lines of simultaneity in S′ parallel to the x′ axis, R1 for the construction to the ct′ axis showing Y's line meets it lower, A1 for Y first. An answer that says "simultaneous in both frames" scores 0 for (b).
Q6. (a) γ = 1 ÷ √(1 − 0.60²) = 1.25. L = L₀/γ = 80 ÷ 1.25 = 64 m. (b) Δt = γΔt₀ = 1.25 × 2.0 = 2.5 s. (c) The observer on the spacecraft measures the proper time, because the lamp is at rest in the spacecraft frame, so successive flashes happen at the same place there. (a) A1. (b) M1 for identifying 2.0 s as Δt₀ and multiplying by γ, A1 for 2.5 s. (c) A1 for the spacecraft with the same-place reason; "because it is the correct time" scores 0.
Educerie · written from the published IB Diploma Programme Physics guide, first assessment 2025, section A.5 Galilean and special relativity. Original text, examples and questions. Diagrams drawn by Educerie. Last reviewed 25 September 2026.