Educerie
Level

Educerie · IB Diploma · Physics

Theme E Nuclear and quantum physics · E.4 Fission

Level
SL and HL. Nothing here is HL only, so every section is examinable for both.
Themes (key concepts)
energy, particles and the nature of science. Fission turns the binding of nucleons into electricity, a chain of neutrons sets how fast, and what is left behind raises a question physics alone cannot settle.
The question this unit answers
in which form is energy stored within the nucleus of the atom, and how can the energy released from it be harnessed?
Where it is examined
Paper 1A multiple choice (the job of a moderator or control rod, balancing a fission equation); Paper 1B data questions, often decay data from fission products; Paper 2 structured questions, where an energy-released calculation is worth 2 to 4 marks, the parts of a reactor 2 to 4 marks, and a discussion of waste or climate change 3 to 4 marks.

What you must be able to do

You must be able toLevelWhat it looks like in the exam
Explain where the energy released in fission comes from, using binding energy per nucleonSL, HL"Explain, with reference to binding energy per nucleon, why energy is released" (3 marks)
Distinguish spontaneous from neutron-induced fission; balance a fission equationSL, HLPaper 1A: "State the number of neutrons produced" (1 mark)
Calculate the energy released in fission, from masses or from binding energiesSL, HL"Calculate, in MeV, the energy released in this reaction" (2 or 3 marks)
Link energy per fission to reactor power and fuel usedSL, HL"Determine the number of fissions per second" (2 marks)
Explain a chain reaction and what keeps it steadySL, HL"Explain what is meant by a chain reaction" (2 marks)
Describe the role of the moderator, control rods, heat exchanger and shieldingSL, HL"Outline the role of the moderator" (2 marks)
Describe the properties of fission products and how they are managedSL, HL"Explain why the products of fission are radioactive" (2 marks); a Paper 1B decay table
Discuss long-term storage of waste, and fission's part in addressing climate changeSL, HL"Discuss one advantage and one disadvantage of nuclear power" (4 marks)

Before you start

From E.3 you need the mass defect, the binding energy (the energy equivalent of the mass defect, from E = mc²) and the curve of binding energy per nucleon, which peaks near iron. From the data booklet: 1 u = 931.5 MeV c⁻² = 1.661 × 10⁻²⁷ kg, and 1 MeV = 1.60 × 10⁻¹³ J. From A.2 you need momentum and kinetic energy in an elastic collision.


1The idea in one paragraph

A heavy nucleus such as uranium-235 is less tightly bound, per nucleon, than a middle-sized one. Split it in two and the nucleons end up more tightly bound, so the products have less mass than what went in. The missing mass is released as energy, mostly as the kinetic energy of the two fragments. That is nuclear fission. Each fission also releases two or three neutrons, which can split further nuclei: a chain reaction. A nuclear power plant holds that chain at a steady rate with control rods, slows the neutrons with a moderator, carries the energy to a heat exchanger that raises steam for a turbine, and keeps the radiation in with shielding. The fragments left behind are radioactive, some for a very long time.

2Where the energy is stored

The energy of fission is stored in the way the nucleons are arranged: it is nuclear potential energy, set by how strongly the strong nuclear force holds each nucleon against the electric repulsion between protons. Binding energy measures it.

The binding energy of a nucleus is the energy needed to separate it completely into its protons and neutrons, which is also the energy released when they come together. Figure 1 plots binding energy per nucleon against nucleon number A.

Figure 1 · Binding energy per nucleon, and the step that fission takes Figure 1 · Binding energy per nucleon, and the step that fission takes Binding energy per nucleon / MeV Nucleon number A 0 2 4 6 8 10 0 50 100 150 200 250 ²H ⁴He ⁵⁶Fe ⁹²Kr ¹⁴¹Ba ²³⁵U +0.8 fission: ²³⁵U → ¹⁴¹Ba + ⁹²Kr 7.6 → about 8.4 MeV per nucleon most tightly bound: iron and nickel light nuclei: fusion releases energy (E.5) Splitting one heavy nucleus into two middle-sized ones raises the binding energy per nucleon by about 0.8 MeV. Multiplied by 236 nucleons, that is the energy released.
Figure 1 · Binding energy per nucleon, and the step that fission takes

Uranium-235 sits at about 7.6 MeV per nucleon; krypton-92 and barium-141 sit at about 8.3 to 8.5 MeV per nucleon. Split uranium into two middle-sized nuclei and every nucleon moves up the curve by roughly 0.8 MeV.

Why is uranium less tightly bound? The strong force has a very short range, so each nucleon is held only by its nearest neighbours, and that attraction per nucleon is about the same in any nucleus that is not tiny. Electric repulsion acts between every pair of protons across the whole nucleus. With 92 protons it adds up and loosens every nucleon. After the split, the two pieces no longer repel each other from inside one nucleus.

Energy is released when nucleons end up more tightly bound. Energy released = total binding energy after − total binding energy before, and it appears as a loss of mass.

Keep the sign straight: binding energy is energy you would have to supply to take a nucleus apart, so more binding means a larger mass defect and less mass.

3Spontaneous and neutron-induced fission

Spontaneous fission is a heavy nucleus splitting on its own. It is random, like any radioactive decay. Uranium-238 does it, but very rarely. Californium-252 splits spontaneously in a few per cent of its decays, which makes it useful as a small neutron source for starting a reactor.

Neutron-induced fission is what a reactor runs on. Figure 2 follows one event.

Figure 2 · One neutron-induced fission of uranium-235 Figure 2 · One neutron-induced fission of uranium-235 n slow neutron ²³⁵U ²³⁶U* excited, unstable, stretches and splits ¹⁴¹Ba ⁹²Kr n n n 3 fast neutrons (about 2 MeV each) fast fragment fast fragment A slow neutron is absorbed, the compound nucleus wobbles apart, and two fragments fly off with two or three new neutrons. About 200 MeV is released, most of it as kinetic energy of the fragments.
Figure 2 · One neutron-induced fission of uranium-235
  1. A slow neutron is absorbed by uranium-235. It has no charge, so there is no repulsion to overcome and even a very slow neutron gets in.
  2. The result is uranium-236 in an excited state, ²³⁶U*.
  3. The excited nucleus oscillates, stretches, and the electric repulsion between its two ends pushes them apart. It splits into two unequal fragments plus two or three neutrons.

One possible outcome:

¹₀n + ²³⁵₉₂U → ²³⁶₉₂U* → ¹⁴¹₅₆Ba + ⁹²₃₆Kr + 3 ¹₀n

Check it balances. Nucleon numbers: 1 + 235 = 236, and 141 + 92 + 3 = 236. Proton numbers: 92 = 56 + 36.

Uranium-235 splits in dozens of ways, usually into one fragment with A near 90 to 100 and another near 135 to 145, with 2.4 neutrons on average. Each fission releases about 200 MeV, over 80% of it as kinetic energy of the fragments. Collisions with the surrounding atoms quickly turn that kinetic energy into internal energy of the fuel.

4Calculating the energy released

Two routes give the same answer.

Route 1: from masses. Energy released = (mass before − mass after) × c², or × 931.5 MeV per u.

Worked example 1. Use the reaction above. Masses: uranium-235 = 235.043930 u, barium-141 = 140.914411 u, krypton-92 = 91.926156 u, neutron = 1.008665 u.

mass before = 235.043930 + 1.008665 = 236.052595 u
mass after = 140.914411 + 91.926156 + 3 × 1.008665 = 235.866562 u
Δm = 236.052595 − 235.866562 = 0.186033 u
energy released = 0.186033 × 931.5 = 173.3 MeV1 u = 931.5 MeV c−2
= 173.3 × 1.60 × 10−13 = 2.77 × 10−11 J

Keep every decimal place until the subtraction, because the answer is a small difference between two large numbers. Count the neutrons: three out means three neutron masses on the right. These are atomic masses, which include electrons, but the 92 electrons of uranium match the 56 + 36 of barium and krypton and cancel.

Route 2: from binding energies. Energy released = total binding energy after − total binding energy before. Total binding energy = binding energy per nucleon × A. A free neutron has none.

Worked example 2. Binding energy per nucleon: uranium-235 7.59 MeV, barium-141 8.33 MeV, krypton-92 8.51 MeV.

BE before = 235 × 7.59 = 1784 MeVthe absorbed neutron adds nothing
BE after = 141 × 8.33 + 92 × 8.51 = 1175 + 783 = 1958 MeV
energy released = 1958 − 1784 = 174 MeV

The routes agree to within rounding. A negative answer means you subtracted the wrong way round.

Worked example 3: energy from a kilogram. If every nucleus in 1.0 kg of uranium-235 undergoes fission at 200 MeV each:

mass of one nucleus ≈ 235 × 1.661 × 10−27 = 3.90 × 10−25 kg
number of nuclei = 1.0 ÷ (3.90 × 10−25) = 2.56 × 1024
energy = 2.56 × 1024 × 200 × 1.60 × 10−13 = 8.2 × 1013 J

Burning a kilogram of coal releases a few times 10⁷ J: fission gives millions of times more per kilogram.

5Chain reactions

Each fission is started by one neutron and releases two or three. If at least one of them causes another fission, the process sustains itself: a chain reaction. Figure 3 shows the two ways it can run.

Figure 3 · A chain reaction, uncontrolled and controlled Figure 3 · A chain reaction, uncontrolled and controlled (a) Uncontrolled: grows (b) Controlled: steady U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U gen 1 1 gen 2 2 gen 3 4 gen 4 8 fissions U 1 U 1 U 1 U 1 absorbed by a control rod escapes or absorbed by ²³⁸U fissions (a) Two neutrons from each fission go on to cause another: the rate doubles every generation. (b) Exactly one goes on; the rest are absorbed or escape. The rate stays steady.
Figure 3 · A chain reaction, uncontrolled and controlled

Not every neutron causes fission: some escape through the surface of the fuel, some are absorbed by uranium-238 or other materials. What matters is k, the average number from each fission that go on to cause another. Figure 4 shows three cases.

Figure 4 · Fissions per generation for three values of k Figure 4 · Fissions per generation for three values of k Fissions in that generation Generation k = 1.1 supercritical k = 1 critical k = 0.9 subcritical 0 5 10 15 20 0 1 2 4 6 k is the number of neutrons from one fission that cause another fission.
Figure 4 · Fissions per generation for three values of k
  • k > 1, supercritical: the rate grows every generation, and a generation lasts a tiny fraction of a second. Uncontrolled, this is a nuclear weapon.
  • k = 1, critical: each fission leads to exactly one more. The power is constant. This is a reactor in steady operation.
  • k < 1, subcritical: the chain dies away.

Neutrons are made throughout the fuel but escape through its surface, and a bigger lump has less surface per unit volume. So there is a critical mass: the smallest mass of fissile material, for a given shape and density, that can sustain a chain reaction. Natural uranium is only 0.7% uranium-235, the rest uranium-238, which absorbs many neutrons without splitting, so reactor fuel is enriched to a few per cent uranium-235.

6Inside a nuclear power plant

A reactor must make fission likely, hold k at exactly 1, get the energy out, and keep the radiation in. The guide names the part that does each; Figure 6 puts them in place.

The moderator slows the neutrons. Fission neutrons are fast, about 2 MeV. Uranium-235 is far more likely to absorb a slow thermal neutron, about 0.025 eV, similar to the kinetic energy of gas particles at room temperature. The neutrons lose energy by colliding many times with the nuclei of the moderator: water, heavy water or graphite.

The moderator must be made of light nuclei. In an elastic collision, a small ball hitting a much heavier one bounces off with almost all its speed; hitting an equal mass head-on, it stops and hands over all its kinetic energy. For a head-on elastic collision with a nucleus of nucleon number A, conservation of momentum and kinetic energy give the fraction the neutron keeps, ((A − 1) ÷ (A + 1))². Figure 5 shows it for four targets.

Figure 5 · How much kinetic energy a neutron keeps in one head-on collision Figure 5 · How much kinetic energy a neutron keeps in one head-on collision hydrogen-1 (water) 0.00 hydrogen-2 (heavy water) 0.11 carbon-12 (graphite) 0.72 uranium-238 0.98 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 fraction of kinetic energy kept = ((A − 1) ÷ (A + 1))² Elastic collision, momentum and kinetic energy both conserved. The lighter the target, the more energy the neutron loses. A uranium nucleus barely slows it at all.
Figure 5 · How much kinetic energy a neutron keeps in one head-on collision

Worked example 4. A 2.0 MeV neutron collides head-on, every time, with carbon-12 nuclei. How many collisions bring it to 0.025 eV?

fraction kept per collision = (11 ÷ 13)2 = 0.716
2.0 × 106 eV × 0.716n = 0.025 eV
0.716n = 1.25 × 10−8
n = ln(1.25 × 10−8) ÷ ln(0.716) = 55

Real collisions are mostly glancing, so about twice as many are needed. Uranium, keeping 98% each time, would need thousands.

The control rods hold k at 1. They are made of a strong neutron absorber, such as boron or cadmium, and moved in and out of the core. Further in, they absorb more neutrons, k falls and the power drops; further out, the power rises. In an emergency they drop fully in and the chain reaction stops. Control rods remove neutrons; the moderator slows them. Swapping the two is the commonest error in this subtopic.

Figure 6 · The parts of a pressurised-water nuclear power plant Figure 6 · The parts of a pressurised-water nuclear power plant concrete and steel shielding moderator and coolant: water fuel rods (enriched U) control rods (boron or cadmium) hot coolant cooled coolant heat exchanger (steam generator) steam turbine G generator to grid condenser cooling water water Fission heats the core; the coolant carries the energy to the heat exchanger, where it boils a separate loop of water. Only that second, non-radioactive loop reaches the turbine.
Figure 6 · The parts of a pressurised-water nuclear power plant

The coolant and heat exchanger get the energy out. A coolant is pumped through the core and carries away the energy that heats the fuel rods. In Figure 6 the coolant is water, kept at high pressure so it stays liquid at around 300 °C, and it is also the moderator. In the heat exchanger the hot coolant flows through pipes surrounded by a separate supply of water; energy passes through the pipe walls and that second supply boils. Its steam drives the turbine and generator, is condensed by cooling water, and returns. The two loops never mix, so the radioactive coolant never reaches the turbine.

The shielding keeps the radiation in. The core emits intense gamma radiation and neutrons. A thick steel pressure vessel inside thick concrete absorbs them, keeping the dose to workers and the public very low, and the containment building is designed to hold radioactive material in if something goes wrong.

Figure 7 · Where the energy goes, for a plant with 3.2 GW of fission power Figure 7 · Where the energy goes, for a plant with 3.2 GW of fission power Nuclear binding energy released in fission Kinetic of fragments and neutrons Thermal internal energy of fuel and coolant Steam heat exchanger boils water Turbine kinetic energy of rotation Electrical 1.1 GW to the grid 3.2 GW 2.1 GW to cooling water and air (the condenser, Figure 6) efficiency ≈ 34% About a third leaves as electrical energy. The rest is transferred to the cooling water and the air, as in any steam-driven power station.
Figure 7 · Where the energy goes, for a plant with 3.2 GW of fission power

Figure 7 traces the energy: binding energy, then kinetic energy of fragments, internal energy of fuel and coolant, steam, the turbine's kinetic energy, and finally electrical energy. The efficiency is about a third, because, as in any steam power station, much of the energy goes to the cooling water to condense the steam.

Worked example 5: from power to fuel. A reactor produces 3.2 GW of thermal power and 1.1 GW of electrical power, with 200 MeV per fission. Determine (a) the efficiency, (b) the fissions per second, (c) the mass of uranium-235 used per day.

(a) efficiency = 1.1 ÷ 3.2 = 0.34 = 34%
(b) energy per fission = 200 × 1.60 × 10−13 = 3.2 × 10−11 J
fissions per second = 3.2 × 109 ÷ (3.2 × 10−11) = 1.0 × 1020 s−1
(c) mass per second = 1.0 × 1020 × 3.90 × 10−25 = 3.9 × 10−5 kg s−1
mass per day = 3.9 × 10−5 × 86 400 = 3.4 kg

That answers the guide's linking question on the rate of energy production: energy per fission, from binding energy, divided into the power gives the rate.

7The products of fission and their management

Why the products are radioactive. Heavy nuclei need more neutrons than protons to be stable, because extra neutrons add strong-force attraction without electric repulsion. Uranium-235 has 143 neutrons to 92 protons, a ratio of about 1.55; stable middle-sized nuclei have about 1.3 to 1.4. The fragments inherit roughly uranium's ratio, so they have too many neutrons. Figure 8 shows them above the line of stability.

Figure 8 · Why fission fragments are radioactive Figure 8 · Why fission fragments are radioactive Neutron number N Proton number Z N = Z line of stability N/Z = 1.55 ²³⁵U ¹⁴¹Ba ⁹²Kr 0 20 40 60 80 100 0 50 100 150 close-up near ¹⁴¹Ba 55 56 57 58 59 60 86 85 84 83 82 81 Z N Ba La Ce Pr each β⁻: Z up 1, N down 1, A stays 141 ¹⁴¹Pr (teal) is stable The fragments keep uranium's high ratio of neutrons to protons, so they lie above the line of stability. Each β⁻ decay turns a neutron into a proton: one step down and to the right, towards stability.
Figure 8 · Why fission fragments are radioactive

A neutron-rich nucleus becomes stable by beta-minus decay: a neutron turns into a proton, emitting an electron and an antineutrino, one step down and to the right in Figure 8. Barium-141 takes three steps to stable praseodymium-141. Most of these decays also emit gamma rays. So fission products:

  • are beta-minus and gamma emitters, because they are neutron-rich;
  • have half-lives from fractions of a second to millions of years: iodine-131 about 8 days, caesium-137 and strontium-90 about 30 years, technetium-99 about 200 000 years;
  • have very high activity when fresh, so they keep producing decay heat after the chain reaction stops. In 2011 at Fukushima Daiichi in Japan the reactors shut down when the earthquake struck, but the tsunami cut the power to the cooling pumps, and decay heat alone melted fuel in three reactors;
  • come mixed with plutonium-239, made when uranium-238 absorbs a neutron and then undergoes two beta decays. It is an alpha emitter with a half-life of about 24 000 years, it is fissile, and it could be used in a weapon.

How the waste is managed. Low-level waste (clothing, tools) is compacted and buried near the surface. Intermediate-level waste (reactor parts, filter resins) is sealed in cement. High-level waste, the spent fuel, follows Figure 9.

Figure 9 · The route spent fuel takes, and how long each stage lasts Figure 9 · The route spent fuel takes, and how long each stage lasts Reactor fuel used for 3 to 6 years Cooling pond under water, which cools and shields · several years Dry casks steel and concrete, air-cooled · decades Conditioning reprocess and vitrify, or seal whole fuel in canisters Deep repository stable rock, hundreds of metres down · many millennia activity and heat output fall all the way along, fastest at the start Every stage has the same two jobs: remove the heat the fission products keep making, and keep their radiation and the material itself away from people and water for as long as it stays dangerous.
Figure 9 · The route spent fuel takes, and how long each stage lasts

It spends years in a cooling pond, where water removes the decay heat and absorbs the radiation; then decades in air-cooled steel and concrete dry casks. Some countries then reprocess it, separating uranium and plutonium for reuse and melting the fission products into glass (vitrification); others seal the whole fuel in canisters. The long-term plan is a deep geological repository, hundreds of metres down in stable rock. Finland has built the first, at Onkalo.

The impact of long-term storage. Weigh both sides.

  • Some waste stays hazardous for tens of thousands of years, longer than any human institution has lasted. A repository must stay sealed through changes in climate and groundwater that nobody can test in advance.
  • It passes a burden, and a cost, to generations who did not use the electricity: an ethical question, not only a technical one.
  • Plutonium must be guarded against theft.
  • Against that: the volume is small for the energy produced, it is solid, contained and tracked, whereas the waste of fossil fuels, carbon dioxide, goes straight into the atmosphere. And its activity only ever decreases.

8Fission and climate change

The guide asks to what extent fission has a role in addressing climate change. For: a fission station emits almost no carbon dioxide while running, and its life-cycle emissions per unit of electricity are similar to wind and far below coal or gas; its fuel is extremely energy-dense; it generates steadily in any weather, complementing wind and solar. Against: long-lived waste, the small but serious risk of accidents, the link to weapons, long and expensive construction, and uranium being a finite, mined resource. A balanced conclusion names the trade-off: large amounts of low-carbon electricity, paid for with a waste and safety problem that outlasts the station by millennia.

9Where marks are lost

Confusing the moderator with the control rods. The moderator slows neutrons so they are more likely to cause fission; control rods absorb neutrons to control the rate.

Saying the energy comes from the neutron or from "breaking bonds". It comes from the increase in binding energy per nucleon, seen as a loss of mass. The incoming neutron brings almost no kinetic energy.

Subtracting the wrong way round. Mass: before − after. Binding energy: after − before.

Forgetting the emitted neutrons. Leave three neutron masses off the right-hand side and the answer is wrong by about 2800 MeV.

Judging stability by total binding energy. Uranium has more total binding energy than krypton but less per nucleon. Stability, and the direction energy is released, go by binding energy per nucleon.

Calling the waste only "dangerous". Give the property: neutron-rich, so beta and gamma emitters, with high activity, decay heat and long half-lives.

10Draw it right

  1. A fission equation balances nucleon numbers and proton numbers separately, with the number of neutrons as a coefficient of ¹₀n.
  2. A binding energy per nucleon graph has A across and binding energy per nucleon in MeV up, rises steeply for light nuclei, peaks near A = 56 at about 8.8 MeV, and falls gently to about 7.6 MeV for uranium.
  3. A chain reaction diagram shows each fission releasing more than one neutron, at least one causing a new fission, and marks the neutrons lost.
  4. A reactor diagram labels fuel rods, control rods, moderator, coolant loop, heat exchanger, the separate steam loop to turbine and generator, and the shielding.
  5. An N–Z graph puts the fragments above the line of stability and shows beta-minus decay as a diagonal step down and to the right.

11Try it

Marks in brackets. Take 1 u = 931.5 MeV c⁻² = 1.661 × 10⁻²⁷ kg and 1 MeV = 1.60 × 10⁻¹³ J. Answers are at the end.

Q1. (Paper 1A style) What is the role of the moderator in a thermal fission reactor? 1 mark

A. To absorb neutrons so the rate of fission stays constant &nbsp;&nbsp; B. To slow neutrons so they are more likely to cause fission &nbsp;&nbsp; C. To transfer thermal energy to the turbine &nbsp;&nbsp; D. To absorb the gamma radiation from the core

Q2. One fission of uranium-235 is ¹₀n + ²³⁵₉₂U → ¹⁴⁰₅₄Xe + ⁹⁴₃₈Sr + x ¹₀n. Masses: uranium-235 = 235.043930 u, xenon-140 = 139.921646 u, strontium-94 = 93.915356 u, neutron = 1.008665 u.

(a) State the value of x. 1 mark

(b) Calculate, in MeV, the energy released in this fission. 3 marks

(c) A research reactor has a thermal power of 500 MW. Assuming every fission is this one, determine the number of fissions per second. 2 marks

(d) Determine the mass of uranium-235 used in one day. 2 marks

Q3. Explain how a chain reaction is sustained in a nuclear reactor, and how the control rods keep the power output constant. 4 marks

Q4. (Paper 1B style) The activity of a sample of mixed fission products, corrected for background, is recorded over 90 days. The data are invented for this question.

Time / days024610306090
Activity / kBq90049629118710450.025.012.5

(a) Show that the activity does not fall with a single half-life. 2 marks

(b) Determine the half-life of the longest-lived component. 2 marks

(c) Predict the activity at 150 days. 2 marks

(d) Suggest why spent fuel is kept in a cooling pond for several years before dry storage. 2 marks

Q5. Discuss the role that nuclear fission can play in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. 4 marks

12In one breath

Fission energy is stored as nuclear potential energy, measured by binding energy: uranium has about 7.6 MeV per nucleon, middle-sized nuclei about 8.4, so splitting uranium raises the total binding energy, lowers the mass, and releases about 200 MeV, mostly as kinetic energy of the fragments. Energy released = (mass before − mass after) × 931.5 MeV per u, or binding energy after − before. Fission is spontaneous or, in a reactor, neutron-induced, and each releases two or three neutrons, so a chain reaction can grow (k > 1) or hold steady (k = 1) above a critical mass of enriched fuel. The moderator's light nuclei slow neutrons by collision; control rods absorb neutrons to hold k = 1; the coolant carries energy to a heat exchanger that boils a separate loop for the turbine; steel and concrete shield the radiation. The products are neutron-rich beta and gamma emitters with decay heat and long half-lives, cooled in ponds, stored in casks, and bound for deep repositories: a burden to weigh against fission's very low carbon emissions.


Answers

Q1. B. A describes the control rods, C the coolant and heat exchanger, D the shielding.

Q2. (a) 1 + 235 = 140 + 94 + x, so x = 2. (b) Mass before = 236.052595 u. Mass after = 139.921646 + 93.915356 + 2 × 1.008665 = 235.854332 u. Δm = 0.198263 u, so energy = 0.198263 × 931.5 = 185 MeV. (c) 184.7 × 1.60 × 10⁻¹³ = 2.955 × 10⁻¹¹ J per fission; 500 × 10⁶ ÷ 2.955 × 10⁻¹¹ = 1.7 × 10¹⁹ s⁻¹. (d) 1.69 × 10¹⁹ × 86 400 × 3.90 × 10⁻²⁵ kg = 0.57 kg. (a) A1. (b) M1 for both mass totals with two neutrons on the right, M1 for Δm × 931.5, A1 for 185 MeV (accept 184 to 185). (c) M1 for converting to joules and dividing, A1. (d) M1 for fissions per day × mass of one nucleus (235 u), A1. ECF throughout. Three neutrons on the right makes Δm negative (−0.810 u); that should be noticed, and scores M0.

Q3. Each fission is caused by one neutron and releases two or three. If on average at least one of them causes another fission, the reaction sustains itself: a chain reaction. Control rods, made of a neutron absorber such as boron, are moved into or out of the core; further in, they absorb more neutrons. They are set so that on average exactly one neutron from each fission causes another, so the fission rate, and the power, stays constant. 1 for more than one neutron per fission, 1 for these causing further fissions, 1 for control rods absorbing neutrons, 1 for exactly one per fission going on / constant rate. "Control rods slow the neutrons" scores 0 for the third mark.

Q4. (a) From 0 to 2 days the activity almost halves (900 to 496 kBq); from 30 to 60 days it takes 30 days to halve (50.0 to 25.0 kBq). The halving time is not constant, so there is more than one half-life. (b) It halves from 30 to 60 and again from 60 to 90 days: 30 days. (c) 150 days is two more half-lives after 90 days: 12.5 ÷ 4 = 3.1 kBq. (d) Fresh spent fuel contains short-lived products with very high activity, which release a great deal of energy as they decay; the water removes this decay heat and absorbs the radiation. After a few years the short-lived products have decayed, and air cooling is enough. (a) M1 comparing early and late halving times, A1 conclusion. (b) M1 using the late data, A1. (c) M1 two half-lives, A1 (accept 3.1 or 3.13). (d) 1 for decay heat from high activity, 1 for water cooling/shielding until it falls. Using the 0 to 2 day data in (b) scores 0.

Q5. Fission emits almost no carbon dioxide while running, and its life-cycle emissions are similar to wind and much lower than coal or gas, so it can replace fossil-fuel generation. Its output is steady in any weather, so it can meet steady demand alongside variable renewables. But it produces waste that must be isolated for thousands of years, carries a risk of accidents, and new stations are expensive and slow to build, so it cannot cut emissions quickly. Conclusion: it can make a significant low-carbon contribution if its waste and safety problems are accepted and managed. 1 for low emissions in operation, 1 for a further advantage, 1 for a relevant disadvantage, 1 for a weighed conclusion. One-sided answers are capped at 2.


Educerie · written from the published IB Diploma Programme Physics guide, first assessment 2025, section E.4 Fission. Original text, examples and questions. Diagrams drawn by Educerie. Last reviewed 25 September 2026.

Mocks: in the future, hold tight!